A free resource from McKenzie Friends, PMA — nonlawyer support for self-represented litigants

Is This Case Real? Check Any Court Case Free

A chatbot, a website or a friend gives you a case to cite. Before it goes in your filing, check four things: that the case exists, that it says what you think, who won, and whether courts still follow it. All four can be done free.

Checklist Free one page, by email

Get the Free Checklist

The cite looked perfect. The case didn't exist.

Chatbots can produce case names and citations that look real and aren't. In Mata v. Avianca, Inc., 678 F. Supp. 3d 443 (S.D.N.Y. 2023), a federal judge fined two lawyers and their firm $5,000 for filing cases ChatGPT had made up. The same judge also wrote that "there is nothing inherently improper about using a reliable artificial intelligence tool for assistance." The problem was filing cases nobody had read.

Step 1

Find the case

  • Go to courtlistener.com, run free by the nonprofit Free Law Project.
  • Type the case name or citation in the search box. A citation looks like "677 F.2d 957": volume, reporter, first page.
  • For Wisconsin Supreme Court and Court of Appeals opinions from 1995 on, the court system's own site, wicourts.gov, has them free.
  • "Not found" does not prove a case is fake; it may be missing from the database. But a case you cannot find and read is a case you should not cite.

Step 2

Find the exact words

  • Open the opinion and use Find in page (Ctrl+F) to search for the words you plan to quote.
  • Read the paragraph around them. A sentence can mean something different in context, and it may be the court describing an argument it rejected.

Step 3

Check who won, and on what

  • Find where the court says what it decides: "We hold," "affirmed," "reversed," "remanded."
  • Example: in Engblom v. Carey, 677 F.2d 957 (2d Cir. 1982), the guards who sued won key legal points on appeal, and the case went back to the trial court. They then lost on qualified immunity, 572 F. Supp. 44 (S.D.N.Y. 1983), affirmed, 724 F.2d 28 (2d Cir. 1983). Quoting the 1982 opinion as a win would mislead the court.
  • Separate opinions (concurrences and dissents) are not the court's holding.

Step 4

See whether courts still follow it

  • CourtListener lists later cases that cite the one you found. Read the newest few to see whether courts still rely on it.
  • This is not a paid citator report (Shepard's or KeyCite). For anything important, say so honestly and keep looking.

Get the One-Page Checklist

All four checks on one printable page, with a case log to fill in. Keep it next to you when you check a case before you cite it.

What We Do

Every quote in our revised Bill of Rights ebooks was checked against its original source, and each book has a verification log.

See the Bill of Rights Bundle

Free Checklist